2017-08-11 416阅读
从SAT到GRE和GMAT,我们能够很清晰的看到GMAT写作考题的设计思路。从中学开始的教材和作文考试就重在培养学生的思辨能力,而逻辑思维能力是必不可少的考察内容,甚至可以说是最重要的部分——GRE和GMAT写作的考察充分体现了这一点。
●●点击获取更多专业名师一对一咨询、免费网上增值服务●● <
其实各种GMAT写作指导书的理论部分不外就是把逻辑基础教材的informal reasoning部分修饰一番搬过来,主要就是讲解informal reasoning常见的错误,根据不同的书的篇幅和详细程度,一般有7-13种,因字数原因,在此不一一详述。因此考生第一步需要熟悉常见的非形式推理错误,因为考题基本上都是根据这些错误设计的。有些题看上去甚至有点傻,不大会出现在现实生活中,因为是特意为考试编写出来的。另外,由于需要适应考试环境的缘故,考题会稍显程式化,形式上比较接近三段式(syllogism),反而方便了考生寻找premises和conclusion。比如下面一道例题:
The following appeared in a memorandum issued by the human-resources department of Capital Bank:
"Capital Bank has always required that its employees wear suits at all times while at work.Last month, Capital’s employee absenteeism and attrition rates both reached all-time highs.In order to reverse these trends, Capital should adopt a company-wide "casual Friday" policy, under which all employees would be permitted, and even encouraged, to dress casually for work every Friday.After all, most companies in the software industry allow their workers to dress casually for work anytime they want; and those workers often remark that this policy enhances their job satisfaction.Moreover, most software firms experience lower rates of employee absenteeism and attrition than companies in other industries, including banking."
Discuss how logically convincing you find this argument.In your discussion, you should analyze the argument&aposs line of reasoning and use of evidence.It may be appropriate in your critique to call into question certain assumptions underlying the argument and/or to indicate what evidence might weaken or strengthen the argument.It may also be appropriate to discuss how you would alter the argument to make it more convincing and/or discuss what additional evidence, if any, would aid in evaluating the argument.
一般情况下,一个argument里头至少有3个错误,有些时候甚至还有5-6个,而找出来这些问题,作文可以说完成了差不多一半了。由于时间限制,建议找最主要的问题写3个,如还有时间,可以继续写。
首先把相应的前提和结论找出来:
Conclusion:
Capital should adopt a company-wide "casual Friday" policy, under which all employees would be permitted, and even encouraged, to dress casually for work every Friday.
Premises:
1.Capital Bank has always required that its employees wear suits at all times while at work.Last month, Capital’s employee absenteeism and attrition rates both reached all-time highs.
2.most companies in the software industry allow their workers to dress casually for work anytime they want; and those workers often remark that this policy enhances their job satisfaction.
3.most software firms experience lower rates of employee absenteeism and attrition than companies in other industries, including banking."
注意,这里并非是三个并列的前提推出最后一个结论,前提中间仍然包含小的结论,因此画一个路线图就是:
Premise 1(premise) Capital bank requires suits ——> (conclusion) high rates
Premise 2 (premise)software companies casual wear ——> (conclusion)1.employee satisfaction and ——>2.low rates————> final conclusion Bank’s casual Friday policy
从上面的分析就可以看出来,每一个箭头代表着一个推理上的漏洞,画一个清晰的图表,有助于理清思路,更容易找到问题所在。这里由于篇幅的原因,就无法一一讲解语言组织等比较细的内容了。
最后,虽然这种试题考的是推理能力,但并不是像纯逻辑学那样只考虑思路是否正确,而是还有对生活常识的涉及,两者结合才能有效的查找题目中的逻辑漏洞。比如题库中的一题提到了public TV的收视率与政府拨款的问题,如果不理解与public TV共存的还有cable TV甚至私人频道,public TV有丰厚的广告收入,而且后两者是靠收费经营、广告甚少的话,就不可能找到public TV的收视率与政府拨款未必有关系这个问题。
GMAT写作的范文网上有很多,但模仿范文有可能被判为抄袭,如果全文背诵范文还有可能被当做雷同卷判为零分,得不偿失。澳际留学在这里建议考生留足备考时间,把题库都过一遍,加强练习,在考试中取得优异成绩。
Copyright 2000 - 2020 北京澳际教育咨询有限公司
www.aoji.cn All Rights Reserved | 京ICP证050284号
总部地址:北京市东城区 灯市口大街33号 国中商业大厦2-3层
高国强 向我咨询
行业年龄 11年
成功案例 2937人
留学关乎到一个家庭的期望以及一个学生的未来,作为一名留学规划导师,我一直坚信最基本且最重要的品质是认真负责的态度。基于对学生和家长认真负责的原则,结合丰富的申请经验,更有效地帮助学生清晰未来发展方向,顺利进入理想院校。
Tara 向我咨询
行业年龄 6年
成功案例 1602人
薛占秋 向我咨询
行业年龄 10年
成功案例 1869人
从业3年来成功协助数百同学拿到英、美、加、澳等各国学习签证,递签成功率90%以上,大大超过同业平均水平。
Cindy 向我咨询
行业年龄 18年
成功案例 4806人
精通各类升学,转学,墨尔本的公立私立初高中,小学,高中升大学的申请流程及入学要求。本科升学研究生,转如入其他学校等服务。